The Strange Thing About the Johnsons: Plot, Cast, Where to Watch

Ari Aster built his reputation on family horror—but his breakout films Hereditary and Midsommar owe their DNA to a far more unsettling origin. The Strange Thing About the Johnsons, his 2011 AFI thesis short, leaked online and sparked fierce debate by refusing to let viewers look away from an incestuous dynamic that inverts every abuse trope media normally serves.

Director: Ari Aster · Release Year: 2011 · Runtime: 29 minutes · Format: Short film · Lead Actors: Billy Mayo, Brandon Greenhouse, Angela Bullock

The key facts table below consolidates verified details from multiple sources for quick reference.

What is the weird story about the Johnsons?

The Strange Thing About the Johnsons is a 2011 American short psychological horror film written and directed by Ari Aster as his thesis project at the AFI Conservatory. The film depicts a suburban family—Stanley Johnson (Billy Mayo), his wife Joan (Angela Bullock), and their son Isaiah (Brandon Greenhouse)—in which the adult son sexually abuses his father in a one-sided incestuous relationship, with the mother aware but silent.

Plot breakdown

• The film opens with 12-year-old Isaiah, establishing early signs of what becomes the “strange thing” as he grows older
• Father Stanley is a published poet who attempts to reveal the abuse through his autobiography
• Isaiah intercepts and gaslights his father, famously telling him: “It takes two to tango”
• The mother Joan remains complicit through silence, maintaining the family’s public facade

Themes explored

The film challenges traditional incest portrayals found in most media by making the son the perpetrator and the father the victim. According to Film Matters Magazine, Aster “set out to make a film about a taboo that was not even a taboo because it was so unfathomable.” The upper-middle-class family setting—complete with American Dream imagery—heightens the horror by showing how such abuse hides behind respectable facades. Themes include family violence, enforced silence, and twisted views on abuse that persist in part because certain patterns are rarely discussed openly.

Where can I watch The Strange Thing About the Johnsons?

The film is not available on major streaming platforms. According to JustWatch, which tracks availability across services, The Strange Thing About the Johnsons does not appear on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, or other standard services in the US or internationally.

YouTube archival upload

The full version is available on YouTube through community reuploads. These archival uploads include multilingual subtitles in English, Portuguese, Italian, Spanish, French, and Ukrainian, making the film accessible to a broader international audience that may have encountered discussions of it online. These reuploads exist because the original AFI prints or festival copies are not widely distributed.

Other platforms

• No official streaming contract exists with major platforms
• Fitness-focused or genre-specialty services do not carry the short
• Physical media or iTunes/Vimeo purchases are not listed in major databases

Is The Strange Thing About the Johnsons worth watching?

This is a difficult film to recommend because it is genuinely uncomfortable to sit through. According to Indie Shorts Mag, the film delivers a “violently frightening depiction of sexual abuse reducing the victim to constant fear, with brilliant sound design.” The 29-minute runtime feels extended because Aster stretches tension without release.

Pros and cons

Viewer reactions

Reviews span a wide spectrum. Morbidly Beautiful describes it as “essential for fans of shock cinema that holds a mirror to society,” while NUS CNM notes it is “not for the faint of heart—it is disturbing, uncomfortable, and leaves a lasting psychological scar without ghosts or jump scares.” The film provoked controversy upon its release and continues to spark strong reactions more than a decade later.

“The Strange Thing About the Johnsons is not a film for the faint of heart. It is disturbing, uncomfortable, and leaves a lasting psychological scar.”

— NUS CNM Review

The pattern among critics shows that Aster’s inversion of abuse tropes generates lasting psychological impact precisely because the film refuses conventional horror crutches.

Is The Strange Thing About the Johnsons a full-length movie?

No, this is a short film. The Strange Thing About the Johnsons runs approximately 29 minutes, which is standard for a thesis project at the AFI Conservatory. The short format serves the story well—Aster sustains dread without needing subplots or character backstory because the horror is entirely in the present moment and power dynamic.

Runtime and style

• Total runtime: 29 minutes
• Filmed as single-camera AFI thesis project in 2011
• Minimal dialogue, heavy reliance on sound design and visual composition
• Uses offscreen sound and cutaways to imply horror rather than show it directly

The implication: Aster already displays his signature approach here—family dysfunction, atmospheric dread, and the suggestion that true horror lies in human relationships rather than supernatural forces.

Who is in the cast of The Strange Thing About the Johnsons?

The cast is small but effective. According to Wikipedia, Billy Mayo plays father Stanley Johnson, Brandon Greenhouse plays son Isaiah, and Angela Bullock plays mother Joan. The tight casting serves the intimate, claustrophobic tone.

Main actors

• Billy Mayo as Stanley Johnson (father, abuse victim, published poet)
• Brandon Greenhouse as Isaiah Johnson (son, perpetrator)
• Angela Bullock as Joan Johnson (mother, silent complicity)
• Carlton Jeffery as young Isaiah (opening scene, age 12)

Director background

Ari Aster created The Strange Thing About the Johnsons as his application and thesis film at the AFI Conservatory. He reportedly conceived the story from taboo discussions with friends, including Brandon Greenhouse, before attending film school. The short premiered at the Slamdance Film Festival on January 22, 2011, then leaked online in January 2011 and went viral—giving Aster an early reputation for provocative content before his feature career launched with Hereditary in 2018.

Related reading: Hot Milk (Film): Plot, Cast, Reviews & 2025 Release Date

Ari Aster first captured attention with Ari Aster’s debut horror short, the 2011 short that boldly exposed hidden family traumas before his feature films.

Frequently asked questions